Manhattan Condo Owners · Expired Listings

For 10 Years I Said Lower Your Price. NOT ANYMORE.

Manhattan condo pricing was flat for a decade. In August 2026 it broke out to a record. Your listing price may have been early. Not wrong.

In late 2015 I issued a report advising of a top in Manhattan real estate prices — you can read it here. For over 10 years, prices trended flat to lower. That trend is now OVER.

Every other agent calling you right now is going to say the same thing: lower your price and relist. That was the right advice for a decade. The data says it's now the wrong advice — and I have the track record to say so.

Before you relist, re-price, or walk away, watch these three UrbanDigs analyses. Then let's talk.

The Setup

The Chart Everyone Is Missing

UrbanDigs: Is Manhattan About to Break the Channel? Resale condo price per square foot, 2008 to 2026

This chart tells a 17-year story in three acts:

Act 1 — Crash & Base (2008–2012): The GFC hammered Manhattan condo prices to a low of $928/sq ft. Owners who sold here locked in the worst outcome.

Act 2 — Post-GFC Bull Run (2012–2016): Prices recovered and climbed at +8%/yr. The golden era. Owners who held through the crash were rewarded.

Act 3 — The Decade-Long Plateau (2016–2026): Prices went sideways — +0%/yr — for over a decade. Headlines screamed "NYC is dying." Pessimism peaked.

And now? In August 2026, Manhattan resale condo price per square foot hit $1,500 — the highest monthly reading in UrbanDigs' data going back to 2008. Q3 2026 ran at $1,508 through late September, above the prior quarterly high of $1,472. The channel didn't just get tested. It broke.

This is what a breakout looks like before it becomes obvious.

Video 1

The 2025 Investment Thesis | UrbanDigs × Noam Newman

Recorded: May 15, 2025

What Noam Said — and Why It Matters Now

In May 2025, commercial real estate veteran Noam Newman laid out a six-point thesis for why Manhattan was approaching an inflection point. At the time, most agents were telling clients to exit. Noam said hold.

Here are the six points — one year later, every single one is tracking:

  1. You're buying at the same price as 10 years ago — in a high-inflation world.
    In real (inflation-adjusted) dollars, Manhattan condos are cheaper today than they were in 2015. That's not a reason to sell. That's a reason to hold and wait for the correction to correct itself.
  2. The math doesn't work for new construction.
    Building permits are down 28% year-over-year. New condo development at attainable price points is essentially impossible — construction costs, land costs, and financing costs don't pencil out below $5M+ per unit. There is no supply wave coming. What's here now is what there will be.
  3. In 1–2 years, the affordability pendulum swings from renting to buying.
    Rents have been rising relentlessly. At some point — and Noam pegged that window at 12–24 months from mid-2025 — renters stop renewing and start buying. That surge in demand hits a market with no new supply. Prices move.
  4. "History Doesn't Repeat Itself, But It Rhymes."
    The setup in 2025–2026 mirrors the setup in 2011–2012 — the lull before the run. Low urgency, flat prices, everyone tired of waiting. Then urgency floods in faster than anyone expected.
  5. The rental market is the lowest barrier of entry.
    For owners who aren't ready to sell or whose units sit vacant, the rental market offers immediate income, market exposure, and optionality. Renting is not giving up — it's positioning.
  6. NYC: house first, job second.
    High-earning professionals are moving to New York for the job market — not leaving it. Commercial occupancy is recovering, Class A office is filling up, and the talent base coming into the city earns significantly more than the prior generation of renters. That earns higher rents, which converts to higher sale prices.

Video 2

The 2026 Investment Thesis | UrbanDigs × Noam Newman

Recorded: Spring 2026

One Year Later — The Thesis Is Playing Out

When Noam returned to UrbanDigs in 2026, the conversation opened with something remarkable: his rent prediction from a year earlier — median Manhattan rents reaching $5,500 — had hit on the literal one-year anniversary of the podcast. To the day.

Here's what's confirmed and what it means:

Rents hit the target. Median Manhattan rents are now at or above $5,500/month. That's not a coincidence — it's the math of constrained supply and rising demand playing out exactly as modeled.

The free market is bearing all the pressure. The 2019 rent stabilization reforms took tens of thousands of units effectively offline — landlords can't recoup renovation costs, so they warehouse units rather than bring them back. That entire demand load has shifted onto free-market units: individually owned condos and free-market rental buildings. Supply is thin. Those owners are setting the price.

Commercial is confirming the thesis. 2 Park Avenue is approaching 90% occupancy. A record-breaking price per square foot just closed at 9 West 57th. Office is back — and the jobs filling it are high-salary finance, healthcare, AI, and technology. Those workers need to live somewhere. They're not going to Brooklyn.

Rental exhaustion is emerging. Renters at the high end — $6,000–$15,000/month — are looking around and realizing they can buy for less than they can renew. One woman in a recent article described touring apartments and ultimately deciding to buy in the same neighborhood because the math flipped. This is the early signal of the transition Noam predicted. It's not at full force yet — but it's here.

The urgency is building — with no inventory to absorb it. The under-$3M market is where the action will happen. Buyers are starting to feel the pull. But because the supply pipeline is dry — and there's a 4–5 year lag between permits and finished product — when that urgency fully arrives, there will be nothing to buy. That's when prices move fast.

Video 3

"Is Manhattan About to Break the Channel?" | UrbanDigs Macro Monday

Recorded: June 15, 2026

What UrbanDigs Said in Real Time — June 2026

This is the most recent read from Noah Rosenblatt and John Walkup at UrbanDigs — and it may be the most important one.

Key observations from June 15, 2026:

New listings are falling below seasonal norms. Supply for the prior 30 days came in at 1,310 listings — below the 1,379 expected for June. As summer begins, new inventory is shrinking. Less competition for sellers. Less choice for buyers.

Contract activity is at multi-year highs. The market has sustained above 1,000 concurrent contracts in play — for longer than any stretch since 2022. This is not a blip. This is a season. The best spring in years.

The price channel is being tested. UrbanDigs drew the lines live on air: resale condo price per square foot has been inside a sideways band for 10+ years. The most recent data point is pressing the top of that band. And because closing data lags contracts by 3 months, the real-time market — the contracts being signed today — is almost certainly already above it.

As Noah put it on air: "You might literally be at 2012 right now with the sales market."

2012 was the year before the golden era began.

Update: two months after this recording, resale condo price per square foot printed a record $1,500 (UrbanDigs, August 2026).

The Bottom Line

Your listing price wasn't wrong. The NYC market just wasn't ready.

When a listing expires, every agent in the city will tell you to drop the price and try again. That's the standard playbook. It's also the playbook that costs you money when the timing is about to shift.

In November 2015, I published a report calling the top of the Manhattan condo market. The market went flat for nearly a decade. For 10 years, telling sellers to lower their price was the right call — and I made it, consistently.

Now the data is telling me the opposite. The price-per-square-foot channel that was flat since 2016 broke out to a record $1,500 in August 2026. Permits are down 28% year-over-year. Rental exhaustion is setting in. Commercial is confirming the recovery. The supply wave that would kill a price run isn't coming.

Your listing price may have been exactly right — just 6 to 12 months early. Re-listing into a market that's moving upward is a completely different conversation than re-listing into a flat one.

If you don't have an urgent reason to sell today, the data makes a strong case for renting strategically, reducing your carrying cost, and letting the market catch up to where you already priced it.

When it does, you won't be negotiating down. You'll be negotiating up.

"But I Need the Equity / I Need to Move On"

That's a completely valid reason to sell — and if that's your situation, Randy will tell you so directly. He's not going to tell you to hold if holding doesn't make sense for your life.

But if the honest answer is "I'd prefer to sell, but I don't have to" — then it's worth a 20-minute conversation about what renting your unit looks like while you wait for the market to do what the data says it's going to do.

There's a version of this where you come out ahead on both ends: income now, appreciation later.

What We Offer

Renting Smart While You Wait

If you're holding and need to rent your unit — or if a vacancy is coming up — ReisNYC's flat-rate commission structure means you get full-service broker marketing at a fraction of the traditional cost.

The ReisNYC Fair Act — Progressive Flat Rate

Monthly RentOur Fee
Under $2,500/mo1 Month's Rent
$2,500–$4,999/mo$2,500 flat
$5,000–$9,999/mo$5,000 flat
$10,000–$24,999/mo$10,000 flat
$25,000+/mo$20,000 flat

Full marketing. Professional photography. Syndication across all major platforms. Qualified tenant screening. Without the full-month's-rent commission on Manhattan units that would otherwise cost $5,000–$15,000+.

You hold the asset. We minimize the cost of carrying it.

Ready to talk through your specific situation?

Randy Reis is a licensed NYC real estate agent who works specifically with condo investors and out-of-state owners. He'll give you a straight read on your unit, your neighborhood, and what the numbers actually say — no pressure, no spin.

The ReisNYC Fair Act is a proprietary commission structure offered by The ReisNYC Team at eXp Realty — it is not affiliated with any government legislation.

Randy Reis is a licensed real estate salesperson, not an attorney or financial advisor. The information on this page reflects his professional opinion and the publicly available market analysis of UrbanDigs. It does not constitute legal or financial advice. Please consult a qualified professional for guidance specific to your situation.